Is it Cheaper to Sand and Refinish Hardwood Floors or Replace?
July 23, 2023
So your hardwood floors don't look like they used to. They look dull in high-traffic areas. There are scratches in the kitchen and near every door. There are stains from when the washing machine started leaking. And you still can't stop looking at the deep scratches and gouges that the movers left behind. The question is, is it cheaper to sand and refinish them, or to replace them?
Both approaches have their merits, and the decision ultimately depends on several factors, including the condition they are in, budget constraints, and personal preferences. Let's take a look at both solutions and compare them.
The Case for Sanding and Refinishing:
Cost-Effective
In almost all cases, sanding and refinishing is more cost-effective than replacing them. Replacing flooring entirely involves significant material costs, labor charges, and potential additional expenses related to removing and disposing of the old flooring.
Preservation of Original Charm
Older homes often boast unique and historically significant hardwood floors. Restoration allows homeowners to preserve the original charm and character of their properties, which can be appealing to those seeking to maintain the home's authenticity, and even sense of history.
Less Disruption
Restoring wood is a less invasive process compared to a full replacement. While refinishing may require the homeowner to temporarily vacate the premises and remove their belongings and furniture, it is typically a quicker and less disruptive process than ripping out and reinstalling new timber.
Eco-Friendly Option
Opting for refinishing over replacement aligns with sustainable living principles. Keeping the same wood prevents unnecessary waste and reduces the demand for new materials, making it a more eco-friendly choice.
Wide Range of Finishing Options
The refinish method provides the opportunity to update the look of your flooring. Homeowners can choose from various stains and finishes to match their evolving tastes and interior design.

The Case for Replacement
Extensive Damage
In cases where the surfaces have suffered extensive damage due to water, termite infestations, or severe warping, replacement might be the more viable solution. Restoration can only address more superficial damage and imperfections, whereas with replacement homeowners start over with a brand new floor.
Desire for a Different Wood Species
If homeowners wish to switch to a different type of hardwood with distinct aesthetics or properties, replacing allows for this level of customization.
Cost-Effective in the Long Run
While sand and refinish methods are generally more affordable upfront, if the existing surfaces require frequent refinishing due to deep scratches or constant heavy wear, the costs can add up over time. In such cases, replacing with more durable hardwood may be a wiser long-term investment.
Aesthetic Overhaul
For those seeking a complete transformation of their living spaces, replacing the flooring offers a fresh start, especially if the current hardwood style does not align with the desired interior design theme.
Factors to Consider
Condition of the Wood
Assess the condition of your hardwood floors. If they are structurally sound with only minor surface imperfections, refinishing could be sufficient and will save you time and money. However, if they are severely damaged, replacement may be necessary.
Budget
Determine your budget and explore cost estimates for both options. If your budget is limited, restoring floors may be the more affordable choice.
Long-Term Plans
Consider your long-term plans for the property. If you intend to sell or rent it in the near future, refinishing might be a cost-effective way to improve the aesthetics and overall value of the home.
Environmental Impact
If environmental sustainability is a priority, refinishing aligns better with eco-friendly practices.
In conclusion, whether it is cheaper to sand and re-finish real wood floors or replace them with new material depends on the specific circumstances of each homeowner. Both options have their advantages and drawbacks, and careful consideration of the condition of the surfaces, budget, and long-term plans should guide the decision-making process. Ultimately, the choice made should not only meet the financial criteria but also align with the homeowner's preferences and values, ensuring a beautiful and long-lasting investment in their home.
If you are interested in refinishing services, give us a call and we can provide you with a free estimate.
You might also like
Blog



Contact Us Today!